Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Impact of transport on land use shows Illawarra at a crossroad

Illawarra transport policy finds itself at a junction regarding congestion and use

Matt Dickson  profile image
by Matt Dickson
Impact of transport on land use shows Illawarra at a crossroad
P14/P14892 circa 1950: Austinmer Methodist Church on Moore Street, Austinmer. Photo from the Collections of Wollongong City Libraries

Moore St in Austinmer was once a busy neighbourhood strip with a bakery, butcher, general store, post office, barber, hairdresser, dentist, doctor, grocery and hardware stores and a chemist.

It was one street providing nearly all of the community’s basic needs within a short walk from home. What happened to all this convenience, social connection and activity? It’s got a lot to do with transport.

Before the 20th century, transport between the Illawarra’s mining villages and the larger town centres was limited to horse-drawn carriages travelling over rudimentary roads and a rail service operating only three to four steam trains each day, so it was essential to live within walking distance of your workplace and to have shops and services nearby to provide daily needs.

These neighbourhood centres in places such as Austinmer were borne of necessity and organised around how far people were happy to walk.

Soon after the first steam trains powered through Bulli in 1887, a German engineer in Mannheim fitted a motor to a tricycle, and within a few decades, towns and cities around the world were being transformed by this new mode of personal transport. The shift to private vehicles has reconstructed the way we organise settlements because this new ability for an individual to travel large distances at high speed at any given time means it is no longer necessary to live within walking distance of work, shops and services. 

This enabled 20th century planners to divide various land uses into separate “zones” which then had to be connected with more main roads, highways and expressways. In addition to carving up the landscape with a network of asphalt, this system created the perfect conditions for new retail models such as supermarkets, which could be located on cheaper, marginal land far from residential areas.

Supermarkets had bulk purchasing power to secure lower wholesale rates which enabled them to control retail prices. Within a few decades, this decimated retail activity in villages throughout the Illawarra, and local shops and services consequently disappeared from Moore St and other neighbourhood strips.

The private vehicle also enabled planners to oversee the broad expansion of low-density residential development to the extent that 67 per cent of all housing in Wollongong LGA is low density. With residential areas being planned to be separated from shops and services, this process effectively established the necessity of car ownership, and these vast areas of very low population densities also created problems for delivery of essential infrastructure including public transport.

The need for government investment in public transport is largely determined by population densities, so under this current metric, low-density residential areas are guaranteed to always have inadequate public transport. As the land release spreads, the population increases but the actual density remains low and public transport isn’t deemed justifiable, so the number of cars increases and the roads get more congested.

We can continue building more roads and bypasses and widening motorways in a vain attempt to solve this problem but we know this always causes worse congestion as the population grows. High-rise apartment towers in the city centres and high-density development in towns without a comprehensive public transport network is the latest government strategy to reduce suburban sprawl in Wollongong and Shellharbour, but this is simplistic and very likely to generate even worse traffic congestion and urban dysfunction.

 Towns and cities around the world have recognised the negative impacts of unrestricted car dependency on liveability, productivity, sustainability and social equity. While most cities are experiencing the extensive consequences of inaction, places such as Paris, London and Helsinki have benefited significantly from a range of measures to promote public transport, reduce private vehicle numbers and generate positive urban renewal. Right now, the Illawarra is at a crossroad, and our elected representatives have a unique opportunity to seriously tackle this issue and embrace the global movement towards a more progressive and sustainable integration of land use planning and transport infrastructure.

With this objective in place, there will be real potential for all of our cities, towns, suburbs and villages to provide convenient, social, resilient and welcoming neighbourhoods like Moore St during the 1930s, where all our daily needs are within a five-minute walk from home, every kid can safely walk or ride to school and car ownership is not a necessity but a matter of personal choice.

If you want to get involved in Illawarra Public Transport Action, email us at serveorganiselearn@gmail.com.

Matt Dickson  profile image
by Matt Dickson

Subscribe to our Weekend newsletter

Don't miss what made news this week + what's on across the Illawarra

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More