What if we found a better way to disagree?
We elect politicians to exercise judgement on our behalf. Yet our political institutions can place considerable pressure on those same people to defend party positions, oppose proposals from the other side, and maintain an appearance of certainty even when the evidence is less than conclusive.
A conversation with a friend recently turned to politics. Not the merits of one party over another, nor the personalities involved, but something more fundamental: the adversarial nature of our political system and whether it continues to serve us as well as it might.
My friend expressed a growing loss of faith in a system where taking a position often seems more important than considering one.
It got me thinking.
We elect politicians to exercise judgement on our behalf. Yet our political institutions can place considerable pressure on those same people to defend party positions, oppose proposals from the other side, and maintain an appearance of certainty even when the evidence is less than conclusive.
I wonder about the personal toll this takes on politicians. How difficult must it sometimes be to publicly defend a position about which you have private reservations? And what happens to good ideas when they emerge from the wrong side of the political divide?
Of course, disagreement is an essential part of democracy. The opposition has an important responsibility to challenge government decisions. But there is a distinction between scrutinising an argument and opposing it simply because of its origin.
Changing one's mind in response to persuasive evidence ought to be a sign of good judgement, not a political liability.
Which brings me to an unfamiliar word: sortition.
Sortition is the selection of people by lottery rather than election. It has ancient democratic roots and is finding renewed interest through citizens' assemblies and deliberative forums.
The idea is relatively straightforward. A representative group of ordinary citizens is selected, given time to examine an issue, hear evidence from different perspectives, question experts and deliberate before reaching conclusions.
We already place considerable trust in randomly selected citizens through our jury system, although deciding a legal case and developing public policy are quite different responsibilities.
Could a similar approach offer something useful to democratic decision-making?
I don't know.
And that is rather the point.
I'm not suggesting that randomly selected citizens would necessarily make better decisions than elected representatives. Nor am I advocating replacing politicians with citizens' assemblies. Elections provide democratic accountability, and elected representatives carry responsibilities that cannot simply be transferred to an unelected group.
But perhaps there is something to be learned by exploring whether the two approaches might complement one another.
Local government could provide an interesting starting point.
Unlike state and federal parliaments, NSW councils do not operate through a formal government-and-opposition structure. Councillors may hold different political views and affiliations, but their collective responsibility is to govern their community.
They also operate within established frameworks of statutory oversight, financial accountability and public scrutiny.
In the Illawarra, where communities share many challenges but retain their individual identities, could there be value in investigating additional ways of bringing informed community judgement into council deliberations?
We already undertake community consultation, of course. But consultation and deliberation are not necessarily the same thing.
Consultation often asks people what they think or want. Deliberation asks them to consider competing evidence, recognise limitations, confront difficult trade-offs and explain how they reached their conclusions.
There is also the question of what happens afterwards.
In Kiama, exercises such as the Gerringong Charrette and the Kiama Town Centre Study have generated substantial community interest and expectations. Questions about the extent to which their recommendations subsequently influenced decisions illustrate an important concern: public participation must have a meaningful and transparent connection to outcomes.
Any new approach would need safeguards. Recommendations should receive a formal response, with reasons given for acceptance or rejection and progress reported where implementation is agreed.
Equally, it must not undermine elected councillors. Quite the opposite. Well-informed, independently developed community recommendations might strengthen their ability to navigate difficult decisions.
The councillors would retain their hands on the tiller.
Perhaps the Illawarra's councils, the University of Wollongong and organisations supporting local government might find value in exploring these possibilities.
An independently evaluated experiment could eventually be worthwhile. Equally, an open examination might reveal other, more effective ways of improving deliberation.
We should be prepared to discover either.
After all, if we are questioning whether political debate has become too concerned with defending predetermined positions, our own inquiry must not begin with one.
I'm not proposing that we abandon representative democracy or that sortition is the answer.
I'm simply wondering whether there might be another way to support those entrusted with making decisions on our behalf.
Surely the possibility is worth discussing.